Server Noob-ish

joelk2

joelk2

joelk2

Soldato
Joined
22 Nov 2010
Posts
5,721
So background on my setup.

I have a N54L filled with drives running WHS11 turned off in my cupboard.
In my old place it ran flawlessly for absolutely years with plex.

When moving a number of years ago I bought myself a little mini pc as my home server with a 4 TB drive and switched to Emby with a number of the arr’s to handle my media. Again it’s been working flawlessly for years but I’m running out of space.

I have an unused desktop some form of Xeon, 32 GB ram, msi 1030 gpu, m.2 boot drive. Which was my Work CAD machine.

I’m looking into the options of turning this into my home server as I’m sure it has more grunt than my little mini pc plus it has plenty of case space to whack drives in.

I don’t want to run WHS11 as it’s old. I currently use windows as it’s familiar but I’m looking at unraid as an option.
It seems to get mentioned allot but also has good support etc.
would this be the way to go? Anything I should be aware of?
 

Demon

Demon

Demon

Soldato
Joined
22 Oct 2002
Posts
8,289
Location
Near Cheltenham
joelk2 said:
So background on my setup.

I have a N54L filled with drives running WHS11 turned off in my cupboard.
In my old place it ran flawlessly for absolutely years with plex.

When moving a number of years ago I bought myself a little mini pc as my home server with a 4 TB drive and switched to Emby with a number of the arr’s to handle my media. Again it’s been working flawlessly for years but I’m running out of space.

I have an unused desktop some form of Xeon, 32 GB ram, msi 1030 gpu, m.2 boot drive. Which was my Work CAD machine.

I’m looking into the options of turning this into my home server as I’m sure it has more grunt than my little mini pc plus it has plenty of case space to whack drives in.

I don’t want to run WHS11 as it’s old. I currently use windows as it’s familiar but I’m looking at unraid as an option.
It seems to get mentioned allot but also has good support etc.
would this be the way to go? Anything I should be aware of?
Click to expand...

Unraid for sure..

I went from running WHS to Windows Server full, to then try various Linux based OS' but in the end tried Unraid, and never looked back..

It's just the right mix of well supported, good curated docker system, more than adequate VM system!

My only comment of things to be aware of is they are shortly going to a subscription model but at the moment they have normal lifetime licences, so you could look at moving up a licence level from the start, but that's entirely up to you, all the licencing tiers do is allow more total drives in your system, they don't feature lock which is useful.
I think they've proven their support to the product to warrant a lower cost subscription model to keep the money coming in for support.. the real strength of unraid is the continual development, the guides, the whole eco-system is great for noobs through to experienced people that just want to get things done quickly.

FYI, You don't need a 'boot' drive, Unraid boots from a USB Stick.

I use my two m.2 slots for a mirrored fast 'cache' drive,. which is useful for keeping all the docker images/docker app data for super fast containers.. it's also useful for speeding up file writes over the network, but that's all optional!
 
Last edited:

joelk2

joelk2

joelk2

Soldato
OP
Joined
22 Nov 2010
Posts
5,721
Demon said:
Unraid for sure..

I went from running WHS to Windows Server full, to then try various Linux based OS' but in the end tried Unraid, and never looked back..

It's just the right mix of well supported, good curated docker system, more than adequate VM system!

My only comment of things to be aware of is they are shortly going to a subscription model but at the moment they have normal lifetime licences, so you could look at moving up a licence level from the start, but that's entirely up to you, all the licencing tiers do is allow more total drives in your system, they don't feature lock which is useful.
I think they've proven their support to the product to warrant a lower cost subscription model to keep the money coming in for support.. the real strength of unraid is the continual development, the guides, the whole eco-system is great for noobs through to experienced people that just want to get things done quickly.

FYI, You don't need a 'boot' drive, Unraid boots from a USB Stick.

I use my two m.2 slots for a mirrored fast 'cache' drive,. which is useful for keeping all the docker images/docker app data for super fast containers.. it's also useful for speeding up file writes over the network, but that's all optional!
Click to expand...
Cheers.

Had a little play tonight and I think the computer I’m using is broke. I wanted to reinstall windows on it anyways just to check it all out etc and the display went off and now it doesn’t display an output.

I didn’t have a chance to test out unraid though.
 

mi9tchy

mi9tchy

mi9tchy

Associate
Joined
16 Mar 2005
Posts
1,015
Location
london
Demon said:
Unraid for sure..

I went from running WHS to Windows Server full, to then try various Linux based OS' but in the end tried Unraid, and never looked back..

It's just the right mix of well supported, good curated docker system, more than adequate VM system!

My only comment of things to be aware of is they are shortly going to a subscription model but at the moment they have normal lifetime licences, so you could look at moving up a licence level from the start, but that's entirely up to you, all the licencing tiers do is allow more total drives in your system, they don't feature lock which is useful.
I think they've proven their support to the product to warrant a lower cost subscription model to keep the money coming in for support.. the real strength of unraid is the continual development, the guides, the whole eco-system is great for noobs through to experienced people that just want to get things done quickly.

FYI, You don't need a 'boot' drive, Unraid boots from a USB Stick.

I use my two m.2 slots for a mirrored fast 'cache' drive,. which is useful for keeping all the docker images/docker app data for super fast containers.. it's also useful for speeding up file writes over the network, but that's all optional!
Click to expand...
+1 for unraid was originally running this on my hp N54L but moved to a a lenovo thinkcenter tiny and the latest is am running this n100 mini pc
 

alex24

alex24

alex24

Soldato
Joined
1 Jan 2008
Posts
11,053
If you’re familiar with Linux based systems then I can recommend the latest Ubuntu LTS as it’s been super stable for me on an old x86 PC used as a server. I’m using the server edition but adding a desktop environment won’t carry much overhead on something powerful. My drives are setup with ZFS. If you’re already Linux literate somewhat then I was toying with the idea of NixOS on my server as it’s running so great on my desktop. Not a good starting point though perhaps. Depends how comfortable you are.

If you’re not familiar with Linux based systems then I heartily can recommend a Linux based system anyway as you’ll have the opportunity to learn about how they work and it ultimately gives you the most flexibility on how you want to setup.

If you’re time poor then Unraid or similar makes sense I guess.

How do you want to configure your storage?
 

joelk2

joelk2

joelk2

Soldato
OP
Joined
22 Nov 2010
Posts
5,721
Finally got my old work pc up and running. Was an i7-8700k with 32gb ram.

I’ve currently set my nvme 500gb and an old 1tb 2.5” as my array.

I’ve setup sab and the arr’s. Folder mapping is a right pain in the ass so this took ages despite following YouTube guides word for word. I still have no clue on how I did it.

Now for the fun part. I want to replace my 2 mixed drives with 1x 2tb drive.

How do I go about doing this without changing any settings I’ve setup.
 

darkblade

darkblade

darkblade

Associate
Joined
29 Nov 2005
Posts
1,072
joelk2 said:
Finally got my old work pc up and running. Was an i7-8700k with 32gb ram.

I’ve currently set my nvme 500gb and an old 1tb 2.5” as my array.

I’ve setup sab and the arr’s. Folder mapping is a right pain in the ass so this took ages despite following YouTube guides word for word. I still have no clue on how I did it.

Now for the fun part. I want to replace my 2 mixed drives with 1x 2tb drive.

How do I go about doing this without changing any settings I’ve setup.
Click to expand...
For long term you might want to think about the cost of running such a machine 24/7. I would use it to try out unraid, and then look to install on something more power efficient.
 

joelk2

joelk2

joelk2

Soldato
OP
Joined
22 Nov 2010
Posts
5,721
darkblade said:
For long term you might want to think about the cost of running such a machine 24/7. I would use it to try out unraid, and then look to install on something more power efficient.
Click to expand...
It would be sitting idle the majority of the time so wouldn’t use that much power I wouldn’t have though?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom