I Disagree it was a good idea but as the other user posted they crippled it too much.
Digital only console yet the storage was only 512gb with expansion option being only MS own one at the time this cost almost the same as the console crazy.
Next yes the ram reduction which made 0 sense you have the previous XB1X which is able to run enhanced titles yet the new S could not at launch.
MS do not care about hardware and always make bad choices in that area.
The other problem with them is they dont care what the fan base wants they want to tell you what you want this switch started to happen in 360 era and this is why the decline happened.
If they wasn't covered by other sectors $$$ wise they would have been in trouble long time ago.